Introduction
Indianapolis, Indiana, once known primarily for its automotive speedway, is now rapidly accelerating as a culinary destination. The downtown area, in particular, has transformed from a business district to a vibrant hub of gastronomy, offering an astounding array of dining experiences. Whether you’re craving an elegant evening, a quick and satisfying lunch, exotic international flavors, or the perfect craft beer pairing, downtown Indianapolis has something to tempt every palate. This guide will navigate you through the city’s best fine dining establishments, casual eateries, multicultural offerings, craft breweries, and sweet treat havens, all conveniently located in the heart of Indy. Get ready to embark on a delicious journey through the best food downtown Indianapolis has to offer.
Elegant Dining Experiences
For a memorable evening of culinary indulgence, downtown Indianapolis boasts a selection of top-tier restaurants that are sure to impress. These are the places where you celebrate milestones, enjoy a romantic date, or simply treat yourself to an extraordinary meal. The ambiance, service, and of course, the food, are all meticulously crafted to provide an unforgettable experience.
The Capital Grille
Located in the heart of downtown, The Capital Grille is an iconic steakhouse renowned for its dry-aged steaks, extensive wine list, and sophisticated atmosphere. The restaurant exudes an air of classic elegance with its dark wood furnishings, attentive service, and impeccable attention to detail. Start your meal with the pan-seared scallops with citrus glaze, followed by their signature bone-in ribeye. Finish with a decadent slice of their flourless chocolate espresso cake. Expect to spend in the higher price range here, but the experience is worth it for special occasions. You’ll find this gem on Illinois Street.
St. Elmo Steak House
No discussion of downtown Indianapolis food is complete without mentioning St. Elmo Steak House. This historic institution has been serving premium steaks and its famous shrimp cocktail since . Its bustling atmosphere, classic décor, and exceptional service make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The spicy horseradish shrimp cocktail is a must-try, followed by one of their expertly grilled steaks. Save room for their classic bread pudding. St. Elmo is located on Illinois Street, just a short walk from Monument Circle.
Vida
For a modern and innovative fine dining experience, Vida offers an elegant setting and contemporary American cuisine. Known for its seasonally-inspired menus and locally-sourced ingredients, Vida provides a farm-to-table dining experience in a stylish urban setting. The restaurant’s tasting menu is a popular choice, allowing diners to sample a variety of their creative dishes. Each dish is a work of art, and the service is impeccable. Vida is located on East New York Street.
Many of these upscale establishments offer stunning views of the city skyline, making them perfect for a special occasion or a memorable night out.
Casual Dining and Quick Bites
Sometimes, you just need a quick, delicious, and affordable meal without sacrificing quality. Luckily, downtown Indianapolis is brimming with casual dining options that cater to a wide range of tastes.
Shapiro’s Delicatessen
A downtown institution, Shapiro’s Delicatessen is a Jewish-style deli that’s been serving up towering sandwiches, soups, and classic deli sides for over a century. Their pastrami and corned beef sandwiches are legendary, and their matzo ball soup is comfort food at its finest. It’s the perfect place to grab a quick and satisfying lunch. Shapiro’s is located on South Meridian Street and is a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic deli fare in downtown Indy.
Nine Irish Brothers
For a hearty and comforting Irish pub experience, Nine Irish Brothers offers traditional Irish fare, a lively atmosphere, and a wide selection of beers. Their fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, and burgers are all popular choices. It’s a great place to grab a casual lunch or dinner with friends. Nine Irish Brothers has several locations throughout Indianapolis, including one on Massachusetts Avenue (Mass Ave), a vibrant street known for its restaurants and nightlife.
City Market
While not a single restaurant, the Indianapolis City Market is home to a diverse collection of vendors offering everything from gourmet pizza and international street food to fresh produce and artisan cheeses. It’s a great place to sample a variety of flavors in one convenient location. Grab a quick bite from one of the vendors and enjoy it in the market’s historic setting. You’ll find it on East Market Street.
International Flavors
The diverse culinary scene in downtown Indianapolis extends to a wide range of international cuisines. Whether you’re craving the bold flavors of Mexico, the delicate artistry of Japanese cuisine, or the rich spices of India, you’ll find it here.
Iozzo’s Garden of Italy
Experience the warmth and flavors of Italy at Iozzo’s Garden of Italy. This family-owned restaurant serves classic Italian dishes in a charming setting. From homemade pasta to wood-fired pizzas, everything is prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is inviting and the service is friendly, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed dinner with family or friends. Iozzo’s is located on South Meridian Street.
Nada
For a vibrant and modern take on Mexican cuisine, Nada offers an energetic atmosphere, creative tacos, and a wide selection of margaritas. It’s a fun and lively place to grab dinner with friends or enjoy a happy hour cocktail. The restaurant’s colorful decor and upbeat music create a festive vibe. Nada is located on West Maryland Street, close to Circle Centre Mall.
Yujo Izakaya
For an authentic Japanese dining experience, Yujo Izakaya serves a variety of small plates, ramen, and sushi in a cozy and intimate setting. The restaurant’s menu features a selection of traditional Japanese dishes, as well as some creative and modern interpretations. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, making it a perfect place to unwind after a long day. You’ll find this hidden treasure on East Washington Street.
Craft Breweries and Gastropubs
Indianapolis has a thriving craft beer scene, and downtown is home to several excellent breweries and gastropubs that offer a combination of delicious food and locally-brewed beers.
Sun King Brewery
A cornerstone of the Indianapolis brewing scene, Sun King Brewery offers a wide selection of craft beers in a lively and inviting taproom. While Sun King doesn’t serve a full food menu, they often partner with local food trucks to provide a variety of culinary options. It’s a great place to sample some of Indy’s best brews. Sun King has multiple locations, including one in downtown Indianapolis on College Avenue.
Taxman Brewing Company
Taxman Brewing Company specializes in Belgian-inspired ales and offers a full food menu with dishes that pair perfectly with their beers. From burgers and sandwiches to more upscale entrees, Taxman provides a delicious and satisfying dining experience. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting. Taxman is located on South Delaware Street.
Sweet Treats and Dessert Spots
No culinary adventure is complete without indulging in something sweet. Downtown Indianapolis has plenty of options for satisfying your sweet tooth, from artisanal ice cream to decadent pastries.
South Bend Chocolate Cafe
A must-visit for chocolate lovers, South Bend Chocolate Cafe offers a wide selection of chocolates, ice cream, and coffee drinks. Their chocolates are made with high-quality ingredients and are perfect for a gift or a personal treat. The cafe also serves sandwiches and light meals. You’ll find this sweet spot on Circle Centre.
The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers
For an unforgettable dessert experience, The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers is a whimsical and enchanting bakery that serves elaborate cakes, pastries, and afternoon tea. The shop’s décor is over-the-top and creates a magical atmosphere. Their cakes are works of art, and the pastries are equally delicious. The Cake Bake Shop is located on North Pennsylvania Street.
Brunch Delights
Brunch has become a weekend ritual for many, and downtown Indianapolis boasts some excellent spots for indulging in a late-morning feast.
Milktooth
Milktooth is known for its innovative and globally-inspired brunch menu. The restaurant’s dishes are creative and flavorful. Milktooth is located on Virginia Avenue.
Wild Eggs
Wild Eggs is a popular brunch chain that offers a wide selection of breakfast and lunch options, from pancakes and omelets to sandwiches and salads. They are known for their creative menu items and generous portions. Wild Eggs is located on North Pennsylvania Street.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
Beyond the well-known establishments, downtown Indianapolis is home to a number of hidden gems and local favorites that offer unique and memorable dining experiences.
The Eagle
The Eagle is known for their fried chicken, Nashville hot chicken, and Southern-inspired sides. The restaurant’s atmosphere is casual and lively, making it a great spot for a fun night out with friends. The Eagle is located on Massachusetts Avenue.
Livery
Livery is a Latin American restaurant that offers a menu of small plates, tacos, and empanadas. The restaurant’s rooftop patio provides a beautiful view of the city skyline. Livery is located on College Avenue.
Tips for Dining in Downtown Indianapolis
Navigating the downtown Indianapolis dining scene can be a breeze with a little planning:
Parking: Downtown Indianapolis offers a variety of parking options, including street parking, parking garages, and valet services. Be sure to check parking rates and regulations before you arrive.
Reservations: For fine dining restaurants, reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.
Transportation: Downtown Indianapolis is easily accessible by public transportation, including buses and the Red Line. Ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft are also readily available.
Walkability: Downtown Indianapolis is a very walkable area, with many restaurants located within close proximity to each other.
Special Events: Check for local events and conventions that may impact restaurant availability and parking.
Conclusion
The downtown Indianapolis food scene is a vibrant and diverse landscape that continues to evolve and impress. From upscale steakhouses to casual delis, international eateries to craft breweries, and sweet treat havens to brunch hot spots, there’s something to satisfy every craving. The sheer variety of options ensures that both locals and visitors can find a culinary experience that perfectly suits their tastes and preferences. Whether you’re seeking an elegant dinner, a quick lunch, or a sweet indulgence, downtown Indianapolis has it all. So, venture forth, explore the city’s culinary treasures, and discover your own favorite dining spots.
Now it’s your turn! What are your favorite restaurants in downtown Indianapolis? Share your recommendations in the comments below!
