Nestled along the shores of Lake Michigan, just north of Chicago, Highland Park, Illinois, exudes a refined charm with its beautifully manicured parks, upscale boutiques, and tree-lined residential streets. But beyond its aesthetic appeal, Highland Park boasts a culinary scene that tantalizes taste buds and satisfies every craving. From cozy cafes and family-friendly pizzerias to sophisticated fine-dining establishments, this vibrant community offers a diverse array of gastronomic experiences waiting to be discovered. If you’re a food enthusiast seeking your next great meal, or a local looking to expand your palate, this guide will lead you through some of the must-try food places in Highland Park. Prepare for a flavorful adventure that showcases the best the area has to offer!
Casual Dining & Quick Bites: Where Comfort Meets Convenience
Sometimes, all you crave is a delicious, no-fuss meal in a relaxed setting. Highland Park delivers on this front with a variety of casual dining options perfect for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a comfortable catch-up with friends.
The Bagel Restaurant & Deli: A Highland Park Institution
A Highland Park staple for decades, The Bagel Restaurant & Deli, situated on Central Avenue, is a go-to spot for classic Jewish deli fare. The atmosphere is bustling and welcoming, and the aroma of freshly baked bagels fills the air. Their menu is extensive, featuring an array of generously portioned sandwiches piled high with corned beef, pastrami, or turkey. The must-try items include their signature overstuffed sandwiches, matzo ball soup, potato pancakes, and of course, their freshly baked bagels with cream cheese. Expect to spend a reasonable amount for a filling meal. The Bagel is a local favorite because it embodies tradition, quality, and that comforting feeling of home.
Piero’s PizzaVilla: Pizza Perfection in a Casual Setting
Located on Skokie Valley Road, Piero’s PizzaVilla is a beloved spot for pizza lovers of all ages. This family-owned establishment is known for its thin-crust pizzas, which are cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and flavorful toppings. In addition to their classic pizzas, Piero’s also offers a variety of Italian dishes, including pasta, salads, and sandwiches. The atmosphere is relaxed and family-friendly, making it a great place to enjoy a casual meal with loved ones. Signature dishes to consider are the classic cheese pizza, the sausage pizza, and the specialty pizzas with unique topping combinations. The prices are moderate and very affordable. Piero’s is a local favorite because it offers consistently delicious pizza and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Norton’s Restaurant: American Classics and Comfort Food
Situated on Central Avenue, Norton’s Restaurant is the perfect spot for American cuisine. Their menu is an array of all-American plates and signature cocktails. Norton’s offers a delightful experience, with generous portions, an old-school ambiance, and a comforting atmosphere. It’s the ideal spot for a relaxed meal with a touch of nostalgia. The must-try items include the fried chicken, burgers, sandwiches, and salads. Expect to pay between moderate and high for a fulfilling dish. Norton’s Restaurant has been a local favorite due to its consistent quality, classic American favorites, and warm atmosphere that keeps customers returning.
Upscale Dining Experiences: Where Elegance Meets Exquisite Cuisine
For those seeking a more refined dining experience, Highland Park offers a selection of upscale restaurants that showcase culinary artistry and impeccable service. These establishments are perfect for special occasions, romantic dinners, or simply indulging in a truly memorable meal.
Abigail’s American Bistro: Sophisticated American Cuisine
Nestled on Central Avenue, Abigail’s American Bistro offers a contemporary twist on classic American cuisine. This refined restaurant boasts an elegant atmosphere, with warm lighting, comfortable seating, and attentive service. The menu features dishes made with seasonal ingredients, prepared with creativity and skill. Must-try items include the seafood dishes, the steaks, and the creative appetizers. Expect to spend a considerable amount for a premium meal. Abigail’s has received numerous accolades for its outstanding food, service, and ambiance, solidifying its reputation as one of Highland Park’s top dining destinations.
Michael’s Chicago Style Red Hots: A Casual Classic with a Modern Twist
Located on Skokie Valley Road, Michael’s Chicago Style Red Hots offers a unique and authentic taste of Chicago’s iconic street food, but with a sophisticated twist. This local favorite combines the casual charm of a hot dog stand with a commitment to quality ingredients and creative preparations. The restaurant’s atmosphere is vibrant and energetic, reflecting the spirit of Chicago. Though famous for the “Chicago Style” Dog, you can also find other American Classics. The signature hot dogs are a must-try, featuring Vienna Beef hot dogs nestled in poppy seed buns and topped with a colorful array of fresh ingredients. Prices are moderate, but the flavor is outstanding. The community adores Michael’s for its dedication to quality, unique flavor and commitment to the community.
Buffo’s Restaurant: Pizza and Italian Cuisine
Buffo’s, located on Skokie Valley Road, is known for its friendly service, classic Italian-American dishes, and casual atmosphere. Popular for lunch and dinner, families frequent Buffo’s for pasta, pizza, and Italian entrees. Expect to spend a moderate amount of money. Signature dishes to try are the spaghetti and meatballs, pizza, and sandwiches.
International Flavors: A Global Gastronomic Adventure
Highland Park’s diverse community is reflected in its international cuisine scene. Whether you’re craving spicy Mexican flavors, fragrant Asian dishes, or hearty Mediterranean fare, you’ll find a restaurant in Highland Park to satisfy your wanderlust.
La Casa de Isaac & Moishe: Authentic Mexican Cuisine
Located on Skokie Valley Road, La Casa de Isaac & Moishe is a family-owned restaurant that serves authentic Mexican cuisine. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the menu features a variety of traditional dishes made with fresh ingredients and flavorful spices. Must-try items include the enchiladas, the tacos, and the mole poblano. Expect to pay a moderate price for a satisfying meal. La Casa de Isaac & Moishe is a local favorite because it offers delicious, authentic Mexican food in a welcoming environment.
Blue Fish: Asian Cuisine
Situated in the heart of Highland Park, Blue Fish serves Japanese cuisine. Known for its fresh seafood, sushi, and creative Japanese dishes, it provides a modern dining experience with a touch of elegance. The ambiance is sleek and contemporary, creating a sophisticated setting for both casual and special occasions. The sushi rolls, seafood dishes, and the wide variety of Sake. The prices are moderate to high. Blue Fish has become a beloved spot for locals and visitors, offering a memorable dining experience that combines exquisite flavors with top-notch service.
Sarpino’s Pizzeria: International Flavor
Located on Second Street, Sarpino’s Pizzeria offers pizza flavors, which are well known for Italian flavors. They also offer catering for all occasions. Expect to pay a very reasonable price for a quick lunch. Sarpino’s offers signature flavors, pizza, pasta, and salad.
Sweet Treats & Desserts: Indulging Your Sweet Tooth
No culinary journey is complete without a stop for dessert. Highland Park boasts a variety of sweet shops and bakeries that offer everything from classic pastries to decadent ice cream creations.
Once Upon A Bagel: A Highland Park Bakery
Located on Skokie Valley Road, Once Upon A Bagel offers a variety of pastries. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the menu features baked goods, deli sandwiches, and bagels.
Dairy Dream: A Classic Highland Park Ice Cream Shop
Dairy Dream, located on Skokie Highway, is a staple for ice cream! Customers adore the various flavors and options to make your own sundae! This spot has been a favorite for locals for years due to its dedication to quality. The prices are moderate and suitable for the whole family.
Nothing Bundt Cakes: The Perfect Dessert
Situated on Skokie Valley Road, Nothing Bundt Cakes serves individual cakes and offers a selection of cake toppers. The prices are moderate, and is a must try.
Hidden Gems & Local Favorites: Discovering the Unsung Heroes
While the established restaurants often get the spotlight, Highland Park is also home to some hidden gems and local favorites that deserve recognition. These smaller establishments often offer unique culinary experiences and a glimpse into the heart of the community. For an authentic taste of Highland Park, venture off the beaten path and discover these unsung heroes.
Beelow’s Northshore: Best Sandwiches in Illinois
Situated on Skokie Valley Road, Beelow’s Northshore offers a variety of sandwiches and homemade soups. Beelow’s menu features classic sandwiches, such as Italian beef, French dip, and grinders, prepared with top-quality ingredients and served on artisan bread. One of the key factors is their dedication to premium meats and cheeses and the perfect pairing of savory soups. The prices are moderate, but you will get the full flavor.
Conclusion: A Food Lover’s Paradise
Highland Park is more than just a picturesque suburb; it’s a vibrant culinary destination that offers something for every taste and budget. From casual eateries to upscale restaurants, international flavors to decadent desserts, Highland Park’s food scene is a delightful tapestry of gastronomic experiences waiting to be explored. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor from out of town, be sure to embark on your own culinary journey through Highland Park and discover the delicious treasures that await. Don’t hesitate to venture beyond the familiar and explore the hidden gems that make this community a true food lover’s paradise. With its diverse offerings, quality ingredients, and passionate chefs, Highland Park is sure to leave you with a satisfied appetite and a craving for more.
For additional information on local restaurants and culinary events in Highland Park, be sure to visit the Highland Park Chamber of Commerce website. Happy eating!
